O'tay Pizza Express

7 Days a Week
Dine in or Carry-Out

Summer Hours
8AM - 11PM
Memorial Day through Labor Day

Winter Hours
Monday - Saturday
10AM - 8PM
Sunday
10AM - 6PM

Pizza using the O'Tay Signature Sauce has been a Marblehead tradition since 1988. Our family has been part of the community since 1981 and we are proud to serve the Marblehead Peninsula and to welcome visitors to this beautiful vacationland.

Phone 419.798.5574
9268 E. Bayshore Rd.
(Just east of Quarry Rd.)
East of Route 53 in Marblehead, Ohio

Bayshore Country Market

Carrying traditional convenience store items:

Beer * Wine
Pop * Milk
Liquor * Cigarettes
Drink Mixes
Chips * Bread
Breakfast Items
Cold Cuts * Condiments
Canned Goods
Toft's Ice Cream
Ice by the Bag
Bait

Featuring Island Wines and Lake Beers